MTLane's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Surface of the Sun]

Nice Remake

This song is from the movie Sunshine. Love the movie, nice remake, since u have the talent to remake a song like this, you should try composing something original using the same synths :D

FortyMedals responds:

sorry for taking so long to respond, yep the movie was outstanding, :) underrated if you ask me, and i do appreciate that comment, thanks so much, i do hope to compose something new soon, thanks again !

[[dB] I'm the Good Guy]

Very nice!

Great work my friend! All it needs is some vocals :D Maybe if you will let me, i would love to record some vocals over this, check out the acoustic track on my page, let me know what you think :)

Decibel responds:

Yeah Sure, try something out! :) Be sure to send it to me though :)

[Out of Sight (update3)]

Nice bro!

I love it, its very good, composition is superb, the only reason I didnt give it a ten is because the kick was too weak, if you add a more heavy kick with some dirty sidechain, your song would be ten time better. :D Keep it up

alanisnotcool responds:

i agree, looking back on this i see so much taht i could quickly make better lol. thanks for listening and for the good advice =)

[The Conquistadores]

HAHA

I knew it was you, amazing composition, I JUST reviewed one of your other songs. Like I said before, you are an amazing ear for music, you very talented, keep up the great work!

samulis responds:

Thanks for the great review, I'm glad you liked the piece. :)

Good luck with your own pieces, I'll try and see if I can check them out sometime.

[Harp Song]

Very Nice

I usually dont like all the video game songs on here and rate them 0, but since its under classical, I cant complain. The song its self was SUPERB. You should consider going to school for music, you have an amazing ear for melody and composition, its quite astounding, you have more talent then most popular songs on here. I might suggest looking into some new plugins with great sounding orchestral instruments and start creating some symphonies, I think you would do amazing. Keep up the good work!

samulis responds:

Thanks again for the kind review! I have taken a year of general music theory and fancy myself a hobbyist musician (trombone), but I certainly am considering at least studying music on the side in college.

I presently use the EWQL Symphonic Orchestra, which is one of the best ones I've found (albeit its price). In the future, I plan to look into getting some more of EW's stuff, as they have an excellent collection.

Regarding symphonies and other epic pieces, I would write them, but I have trouble keeping myself from getting too many melodies going. A ten-minute movement of mine would probably have upwards of ten independent motifs, some of which only are heard once... which would make it hard to call a symphony. One of these days I'll sit down and try to work with just a few... eventually. :D

[Balkan Rockout]

Not Bad

The song was a bit short but the composition was good, great job on mixing and mastering. 2.40 / 5.00 (+ 0.081)

BloodyN00b responds:

Yes, it's short and action packed. Besides, I wanted to leave you with a feeling of wanting just a little bit more at the end. I'm hoping it might inspire some thoughts.

[SH - Persistence]

Very Nice

Composition and flow is superb. Piano was very nice and so was the sax, nice bass to fill it in. the only thing I found was your instruments were fighting with each other, and there were some imbalances with the mix, Im not sure if you can tell but the volume would fluctuate at certain points. I might suggest adding some sidechain on the drums and find out what is causing the problem, other than that, you are very talented, I enjoyed the song alot!

[Sleepy Dreamscape]

Nice lofty sound

You need to soften the leads with some delay or reverb, they should sit in the mix not out of it (trust your ears)

[Asctttnlal (a Demo)]

Yea

No real direction or composition. I cant rate anything above a 5 because I have nothing to judge by. I gave it a 6 because I'm assuming its not a song but a demo? The sounds/effects are pretty cool. Now take those samples and make some music :)

[Faith Without Sunlight]

Yea

Your song has no real beat, no composition or direction, just some cool distortion. I think if you put your mind to it, you could make some really awesome music, maybe try picking up an acoustic and start singing :D I gave you a 4 because you did change it up a little in the middle.

Viper responds:

yeah...well its just me and a guitar so there isn't really anything else i can add...

i can take my sister's bass and add some bass to it.
and change the solo to something i can remember get some vocals and drums and re-upload it when its completely done

and yeah i did change it up...
i completely forgot a good majority of the song halfway through that solo

i have an acoustic it has electric strings on it and it has a pickup on it
and i don't think anyone would wanna hear my singing...
well maybe a few...
but i'm not that good at singing